Chocolate milkshakes — prices compared

The standard chocolate shake at each chain that sells one, at its most common size.

The verdict: Chick-fil-A is cheapest — the Chocolate Milkshake runs a median $4.95 across 131 sampled stores, 10% below the priciest (Arby's, $5.49). For protein value, Sonic leads: 2.8g of protein per $1 (14g protein at $4.99).

The gap: cheapest vs priciest

Median sampled prices, cheapest against priciest. Picking Chick-fil-A over Arby's saves $0.54 on this item — 10% less. The striped segment is the difference itself, drawn to the same scale.

Chick-fil-A — cheapest
$4.95
Arby's — priciest
$5.49
The difference
$0.54 · 10%
Chocolate Milkshake — AI-generated illustration
Chick-fil-A · standard shake
$4.95
median sampled price
Typical range $4.89–$5.39 · n=131 stores · checked Nov 18, 2026
Med Chocolate Classic Shake — AI-generated illustration
Sonic · medium classic shake
$4.99
median sampled price
Typical range $4.49–$5.99 · n=126 stores · checked Nov 18, 2026
Chocolate Shake — AI-generated illustration
Jack in the Box · regular shake
$4.99
median sampled price
Typical range $4.19–$5.99 · n=132 stores · checked Nov 18, 2026
Chocolate Shake — AI-generated illustration
Arby's · standard shake
$5.49
median sampled price
Typical range $5.19–$5.99 · n=126 stores · checked Nov 18, 2026

Median price, cheapest first

Bar length is the median sampled price of each chain's representative item. Sizes are not identical — the size note under each bar says exactly what was priced.

1 Chocolate Milkshake — AI-generated illustration
Chick-fil-A · standard shake · typical range $4.89–$5.39 · n=131
2 Med Chocolate Classic Shake — AI-generated illustration
Sonic · medium classic shake · typical range $4.49–$5.99 · n=126
3 Chocolate Shake — AI-generated illustration
Jack in the Box · regular shake · typical range $4.19–$5.99 · n=132
4 Chocolate Shake — AI-generated illustration
Arby's · standard shake · typical range $5.19–$5.99 · n=126

Nutrition, side by side

Official published values for the same representative items. A dash means the chain does not publish that value for the item (Jersey Mike's publishes no per-item nutrition — its calories are not shown rather than estimated here). Wingstop values are the official across-flavor ranges.

ItemChainMedian priceCaloriesProteinProtein per $1
Chocolate Milkshake Chick-fil-A $4.95 600 12g 2.4g
Med Chocolate Classic Shake Sonic $4.99 720 14g 2.8g
Chocolate Shake Jack in the Box $4.99 670 14g 2.8g
Chocolate Shake Arby's $5.49 — — —

How to read this comparison

Each chain is represented by the closest equivalent item on its current menu, priced from that chain's own sampled stores (n shown on every card; every representative item is backed by at least 20 stores). Prices are medians with the middle-80% range — the typical range across sampled stores — sampled Nov 18, 2026. Portion sizes differ between chains and are labeled on each card; where a class is sold by the piece, the per-piece price is shown so the comparison stays honest. Nutrition is the chains' official published data only.

More comparisons: Chicken sandwiches · Burgers · Chicken tenders & nuggets · Fries · Soft drinks · all comparisons